Bioenergy Technology Selection Matrix

graphic
graphic

Technology Descriptions

The following are descriptions of different bioenergy technologies:

Direct Combustion

Pile burners
Sometimes called “wet cells.” Burns solid materials in a pile. Can accept a wide range of particle sizes. Simple in construction and therefore relatively inexpensive. Can handle stringy materials but has poor turndown. Also includes big bale and “whole tree” burners. Can range in size from residential stoves to several million Btuh.

Grate burners
Includes two kinds of grates: stationary and traveling. Requires particles sufficient in size to not fall through the grate. Provides a method of cofiring.

Suspension burners
One method is to suspend the particles by centrifugal force in a cyclonic burner. A second method is with an “air stoker” which blows the material into the combustion chamber above a grate with combustion air. Requires small dry particles so they will burn quickly while in suspension; therefore, sometimes used with biomass pulverizers.

Fluidized bed burners
Fluidized bed burners consist of a bed of hot, inert small particles (such as sand) that can be fluidized by gas injected from beneath the bed. Particles injected into the bed or above the bed burn while suspended in the bed. Can accept a wide range of particle sizes including stringy materials and has infinite turndown, but is the most expensive burner system.

Cofiring
Usually means burning wood together with coal; however, it can be other biomass materials and other fossil fuels. Typically cofiring is down either with a commercial-scale grate burner or in a pulverized coal utility boiler. If in a grate, particles must be big enough to not fall through the grate. If passed through a coal pulverizer, wood particles must be 0.25-inch maximum.

Thermal gasification

Fixed bed
Fixed bed gasifiers include cross-flow, updraft, and downdraft, with the latter the most common and producing the highest quality gas. Producer gas has an energy content of roughly 150 Btu/cf; about 15% that of natural gas.

Fluidized bed
Fluidized bed gasifiers operate either without oxygen or with limited oxygen and consist of a bed of hot, inert small particles (such as sand) that can be fluidized by gas injected from beneath the bed. Can handle a range of biomass particle sizes and shapes including mixtures.

Pyrolysis

Slow
Slow pyrolysis systems are basically thermal gasification systems that are “tuned” to maximize charcoal yields, which are on the order of 25%. The processes may be in the form of continuous furnaces, or closed vessels (retorts), or kilns. Charcoal plants range from 50 to several hundred tons of input per day. All charcoal in the US is made from wood and its primary markets are for recreational cooking and activated carbon.

Fast
Fast pyrolysis systems are basically thermal gasification systems that are “tuned” to maximize distillate (pyrolysis oil) yields, which are on the order of 60-70% with wood. Distillates have roughly 75,000 to 80,000 Btu/gal. The largest commercial fast pyrolysis plants are on the order of 60-70 tons per day input.

Other

Thermal Depolymerization
A process that mixes biomass with water and reacts it at high pressures to breakdown the biomass and create distillate products. One commercial plant has a capacity of 200 tons per day of input.

Hydrolysis / Fermentation
Fermentation processes use micro-organisms to digest sugars in the biomass to ethanol or other liquid fuel products. If the biomass is in the form starch or cellulose, it must be broken down (hydrolyzed) into simple sugars compatible with the micro-organisms. Most ethanol plants being constructed today are between 50 and 100 million annual gallons of capacity.

Bio-gasification
A type of fermentation process, anaerobic digestion is a bio-gasification process used to breakdown wastewaters or animal manures in slurry form. Produces a biogas that is half carbon dioxide and half methane, and has roughly 500-700 Btu/cf (versus natural gas at 1000 Btu/cf). Can substitute for natural gas.

Chemical / Esterification
In this context, usually refers to reacting animal fats, waste greases, and vegetable oils with ethanol or methanol catalysts to produce a liquid fuel product (an ester or more commonly, biodiesel) than can be easily substituted for diesel fuels. Biodiesel plants typically range from 3 to 10 million gallons per year annual capacity.

Mechanical

Pellets
Biomass materials that are ground to a dimension less than the pellet diameter can be compressed into pellets with ring-die machines. Typically sold in bags and used for residential heating and typically has dimensions of 0.25-inch to 0.5-inch. Not cost effective if the material is not already at least already partially ground up. Pellet plants typically produce 2-5 tons per hour. Virtually all pellets are made from wood.

Briquettes / Pressed Logs
Briquettes and pressed logs are formed by compressing the ground up biomass material through a die. Typically used for fireplaces or campfires although briquetting sometimes done to increase biomass density for transportation. Briquette and pressed log plants typically produce 2 to 5 tons per hour.

Emerging Conversion Technologies

Ethanol from Cellulose: Hydrolysis
Uses either acid or enzymes to break down cellulose based materials (e.g., trees, grasses, MSW) into simple sugars which can be fermented into ethanol or liquid fuel products. Usually requires a mild acid pretreatment process to expose the cellulose. The Iogen Company’s enzyme-based process is closest to commercialization.

Ethanol from Cellulose: thermal gasification
One method thermally gasifies the biomass materials, and then passes the gases and vapors across a catalyst which converts them into ethanol. A second method thermally gasifies the biomass materials, and then passes the gases and vapors through a fermentation tank where specialized micro-organisms convert the biomass into ethanol.

Liquefaction

Dimethyl ether (DME)
Although commercial in other parts of the world, no DME is produced in the US.

Fisher-Tropisch
Fisher Tropisch process first gasifies the biomass and then passes the gas across a catalyst where it is converted into liquids. These liquids can be used for chemical feedstocks or used either by themselves or in blends with fossil diesel to fuel diesel engines.

Whole Tree Burners
Part of an overall system for harvesting whole trees, transporting these whole trees to a storage pile under an air inflated dome at the power plant for drying, then burning the whole segments of the trees with lengths up to 20 feet at time in a giant pile burner. Prototypes of the burners have been built and tested in Minnesota. The trees are typically grown as short rotation crops, so that they have relatively long stems with small branches, which allows them to be easily managed in stacks.

Stirling engines

Thermal-gasification to recip engines


About the Partnership | Potential Biomass Feedstocks | Potential Energy Products | Technology Descriptions
State Bioenergy Coordinators | Bioenergy Vendor Questions | Other Sites | Contact Us | Home